Ebenezer
It’s tough to make another adaptation of a well-worn classic and especially tough when The Muppets have previously aced the formula.
Nonetheless, Ti West has dropped an, arguably slightly early, new version of A Christmas Carol with Ebenezer.
Straight off, this probably won’t be one to get you into the Christmas spirit and has all the darkness, frights and Johnny Depp you'd expect from a Halloween film instead.
West goes full Dickensian here, with a bleak and faithfully old-fashioned feeling version of the story.
It’s important to stress that this is indeed as bleak as the midwinter.
Whilst the advertising somewhat skews what you’re getting into (a child-friendly, family blockbuster this ain’t) it is a satisfying way of telling the story and some of the elements are high-class (the old-fashioned text cards are lovely as an example.)
West is a modern horror icon and plays those cards accordingly.
The spirits are properly creepy (especially Andrea Riseborough’s ghost of Christmas past [shudder]) and, whilst there are a few passes at levity, it keeps within its literary lane in the main.
Those comedic moments mainly come via Depp, who is in full ‘character mode’ as Scrooge.
For those who like his schtick, it mostly works (and he’s pretty much in every shot of the film so if you’re not a fan steer clear) but he doesn’t quite sell the morality of the tale and the full circle character development we know Scrooge goes through.
There are some great tender moments but the tongue, as always, feels slightly wedged in cheek and it feels like a caricature, pantomime version of a Dickens character dropped into a very much Dickensian London setting and story.
Perhaps worst of all, it simply isn’t very Christmassy.
A Christmas Carol is more of a morality tale but The Muppets just aced telling this story in double-quick time and made you feel the magic of the season (and added songs for good measure.)
Here, the story takes twice as long initially before rushing through its Christmas day denouement with nary a whiff of Christmas cheer to be felt. The lack of colour really hurts it here.
Ebenezer is a high-class version of a classic story and imbued with some great and creepy elements and a proper Dickensian feel.
But, really, who is this actually for?
It’s never going to be a family Christmas classic and hasn’t even been marketed towards the audience that might actually like it best (those who like their Christmas films with a more Gothic/horror lean so, basically, fans of Batman Returns.)
A Christmas humbug. Tasty, but you probably wouldn’t actually want one on Christmas Day when there's so many other delights to enjoy.
⭐️⭐️⭐️

Comments